Most Florida fence jobs come down to one question: vinyl or aluminum. Both last in the sun, and neither rusts or rots. The right choice depends on what the fence has to do.
Start with the job
- Need privacy around a backyard? Vinyl privacy gives a solid screen.
- Need airflow and a screened view? Vinyl semi-privacy lets air and light through.
- Need an open view of a pool, lake or garden? Aluminum keeps the sightline clear.
- Building a pool barrier? Aluminum with self-closing, self-latching gates is the usual choice, and the rules are strict. See our pool fence guide.
Side by side
| Feature | Vinyl (Homeland) | Aluminum (Antebellum, Iron World) |
|---|---|---|
| Look | Solid or spaced boards and pickets | Open pickets and rails, with spear, flat and custom tops |
| Privacy | Full privacy with solid boards | Open by design. Tighter spacing available |
| Colors | White, tan, light gray, dark gray, mocha walnut | Black, bronze, white |
| Upkeep | No painting. Rinse when dirty | No painting. Powder coat does not rust |
| Heat | Medium and dark colors need stiffeners | Open design lets air through |
| Slopes | Stepped or raked sections, depending on the style | Panels can be racked to follow the grade |
| Warranty | Limited lifetime for homeowners, 30 years commercial | Lifetime limited residential. Commercial 20 to 30 years by brand |
Think about the Florida sun
Cheap vinyl yellows and chalks in strong sun. Homeland vinyl has UV inhibitors in every fence profile, which is one reason we sell only Homeland. Aluminum is protected by an AAMA 2604 architectural-grade powder coat. Either way, choose a fence from a manufacturer that publishes its specs and stands behind a written warranty.
Check the rules before you order
Height limits, setbacks and pool barrier rules come from your city, county and HOA, not from the material. In the City of Orlando, for example, fences are limited to 4 ft in front yards and 6 ft in side and rear yards. Read our Orlando permit guide before you pick a height.
Not sure? Send us the job
Tell us what the fence has to do, the footage and where the gates go. We recommend a style and prepare your quote the same business day.
